| Rank | Player | XP% | Years | Teams |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Mike Hollis | 100.000% | 1995-2002 | jax |
| Tony Franklin | 100.000% | 1979-1988 | 2TM | |
| Nick Folk (27) | 100.000% | 2007-2012 | nyj | |
| Jay Feely (35) | 100.000% | 2001-2012 | 2TM | |
| Jason Elam | 100.000% | 1993-2009 | 2TM | |
| Tom Dempsey | 100.000% | 1969-1979 | ram | |
| Al Del Greco | 100.000% | 1984-2000 | oti | |
| Phil Dawson (36) | 100.000% | 1999-2012 | cle | |
| Rick Danmeier | 100.000% | 1977-1982 | min | |
| Brad Daluiso | 100.000% | 1991-2001 | nyg | |
| Toni Fritsch | 100.000% | 1971-1982 | 2TM | |
| Bruce Gossett | 100.000% | 1964-1974 | sfo | |
| Garrett Hartley (25) | 100.000% | 2008-2012 | nor | |
| Jason Hanson (41) | 100.000% | 1992-2012 | det | |
| John Hall | 100.000% | 1997-2006 | nyj | |
| Ali Haji-Sheikh | 100.000% | 1983-1987 | was | |
| Lou Groza+ | 100.000% | 1946-1967 | cle | |
| Dave Green | 100.000% | 1973-1978 | cin | |
| Martin Gramatica | 100.000% | 1999-2008 | tam | |
| Robbie Gould (29) | 100.000% | 2005-2012 | chi | |
| Stephen Gostkowski (27) | 100.000% | 2006-2012 | nwe | |
| Billy Cundiff (31) | 100.000% | 2002-2012 | rav | |
| Mason Crosby (27) | 100.000% | 2007-2012 | gnb | |
| George Blanda+ | 100.000% | 1949-1975 | 2TM | |
| Cary Blanchard | 100.000% | 1992-2000 | clt | |
| George Blair | 100.000% | 1961-1964 | sdg | |
| Dean Biasucci | 100.000% | 1984-1995 | clt | |
| Rolf Benirschke | 100.000% | 1977-1986 | sdg | |
| Chris Bahr | 100.000% | 1976-1989 | rai | |
| Jess Atkinson | 100.000% | 1985-1988 | was | |
| Morten Andersen | 100.000% | 1982-2007 | 3TM | |
| Gary Anderson | 100.000% | 1982-2004 | 4TM | |
| Chris Boniol | 100.000% | 1994-1999 | dal | |
| Jim Breech | 100.000% | 1979-1992 | cin | |
| Frank Corral | 100.000% | 1978-1981 | ram | |
| Brett Conway | 100.000% | 1998-2003 | was | |
| Don Cockroft | 100.000% | 1968-1980 | cle | |
| Mike Clark | 100.000% | 1963-1973 | dal | |
| John Carney | 100.000% | 1988-2010 | nor | |
| Kevin Butler | 100.000% | 1985-1997 | chi | |
| Matt Bryant (36) | 100.000% | 2002-2012 | 2TM | |
| Kris Brown | 100.000% | 1999-2010 | pit | |
| Josh Brown (32) | 100.000% | 2003-2012 | sea | |
| David Akers (37) | 100.000% | 1998-2012 | 2TM | |
| Paul Hornung+ | 100.000% | 1957-1966 | gnb | |
| Tony Zendejas | 100.000% | 1985-1995 | oti | |
| John Smith | 100.000% | 1974-1983 | nwe | |
| Rafael Septien | 100.000% | 1977-1986 | dal | |
| Josh Scobee (29) | 100.000% | 2004-2012 | jax | |
| Roger Ruzek | 100.000% | 1987-1993 | phi |