| 1. | Eddie Brown | 11 | Washington Redskins vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, October 9, 1977 |
| 2. | Ronnie Harris | 10 | New England Patriots vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, December 5, 1993 |
| Mike Nelms | 10 | Washington Redskins vs. New Orleans Saints, December 26, 1982 |
| Theo Bell | 10 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Buffalo Bills, December 16, 1979 |
| 5. | Nesby Glasgow | 9 | Baltimore Colts vs. Kansas City Chiefs, September 2, 1979 |
| Butch Johnson | 9 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Buffalo Bills, November 15, 1976 |
| Rodger Bird | 9 | Oakland Raiders vs. Denver Broncos, September 10, 1967 |
| Leon Bright | 9 | New York Giants vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 11, 1982 |
| Steve Smith (23) | 9 | Carolina Panthers vs. Detroit Lions, September 15, 2002 |
| Phil McConkey | 9 | New York Giants vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 6, 1987 |
| Andre Hastings | 9 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Cleveland Browns, November 13, 1995 |
| Tony Leonard | 9 | San Francisco 49ers vs. New Orleans Saints, October 17, 1976 |
| Cleo Montgomery | 9 | Los Angeles Raiders vs. Detroit Lions, December 10, 1984 |
| Mike Nelms | 9 | Washington Redskins vs. St. Louis Cardinals, December 21, 1980 |
| Pete Shaw | 9 | New York Giants vs. Philadelphia Eagles, November 20, 1983 |
| Ralph McGill | 9 | San Francisco 49ers vs. Atlanta Falcons, October 29, 1972 |
| Reggie Swinton | 9 | Arizona Cardinals vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 24, 2005 |
| Larry Marshall | 9 | Philadelphia Eagles vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, September 18, 1977 |
| 19. | Quan Cosby (29) | 8 | Denver Broncos vs. Chicago Bears, December 11, 2011 |
| Howard Stevens | 8 | Baltimore Colts vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, October 3, 1976 |
| Tim Dwight | 8 | Atlanta Falcons vs. Detroit Lions, November 12, 2000 |
| Evan Cooper | 8 | Philadelphia Eagles vs. San Diego Chargers, October 26, 1986 |
| Leon Johnson | 8 | San Diego Chargers vs. Detroit Lions, December 7, 2003 |
| Phil McConkey | 8 | San Diego Chargers vs. Indianapolis Colts, November 26, 1989 |
| Trindon Holliday (26) | 8 | Denver Broncos vs. Carolina Panthers, November 11, 2012 |
| Eddie Payton | 8 | Detroit Lions vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, November 20, 1977 |
| Desmond Howard | 8 | Oakland Raiders vs. San Diego Chargers, October 11, 1998 |
| Latario Rachal | 8 | San Diego Chargers vs. Oakland Raiders, October 11, 1998 |
| Paul Skansi | 8 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, October 30, 1983 |
| Mike Fuller | 8 | San Diego Chargers vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, September 19, 1976 |
| Kyle Williams (23) | 8 | San Francisco 49ers vs. New York Giants, January 22, 2012 |
| Mike Nelms | 8 | Washington Redskins vs. Chicago Bears, October 11, 1981 |
| Phil McConkey | 8 | New York Giants vs. Dallas Cowboys, November 4, 1984 |
| Neal Colzie | 8 | Oakland Raiders vs. San Diego Chargers, October 5, 1975 |
| Ray Williams | 8 | Detroit Lions vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, December 14, 1980 |
| Terry Fair | 8 | Detroit Lions vs. Philadelphia Eagles, November 8, 1998 |
| Ted Watts | 8 | Oakland Raiders vs. New England Patriots, November 1, 1981 |
| Jeff Fisher | 8 | Chicago Bears vs. Detroit Lions, December 16, 1984 |
| Kevin Miller | 8 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 2, 1979 |
| Dedric Ward | 8 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Washington Redskins, September 27, 2004 |
| Rick Upchurch | 8 | Denver Broncos vs. Baltimore Colts, October 22, 1978 |
| Phil Epps | 8 | Green Bay Packers vs. Minnesota Vikings, November 21, 1982 |
| Leon Bright | 8 | New York Giants vs. Washington Redskins, September 13, 1981 |
| DeSean Jackson (22) | 8 | Philadelphia Eagles vs. St. Louis Rams, September 7, 2008 |
| Ron Fellows | 8 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Cleveland Browns, November 25, 1982 |
| Stump Mitchell | 8 | St. Louis Cardinals vs. Washington Redskins, January 2, 1983 |
| Willie Sydnor | 8 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. New England Patriots, December 26, 1982 |
| Fulton Walker | 8 | Los Angeles Raiders vs. Cleveland Browns, November 16, 1986 |
| Tommy Pharr | 8 | Buffalo Bills vs. New York Jets, October 25, 1970 |
| Adam Jones (22) | 8 | Tennessee Titans vs. Miami Dolphins, December 24, 2005 |