| 1. | Clarke Hinkle+ | 2 | Green Bay Packers vs. New York Giants, December 10, 1939 |
| Kyle Richardson | 2 | Baltimore Ravens vs. Tennessee Titans, January 7, 2001 |
| Riley Smith | 2 | Boston Redskins vs. Green Bay Packers, December 13, 1936 |
| 4. | Sammy Baugh+ | 1 | Washington Redskins vs. Chicago Bears, December 12, 1937 |
| Josh Bidwell | 1 | Green Bay Packers vs. Atlanta Falcons, January 4, 2003 |
| Ed Brown | 1 | Chicago Bears vs. New York Giants, December 30, 1956 |
| Maury Buford | 1 | Chicago Bears vs. Dallas Cowboys, December 29, 1991 |
| Rich Camarillo | 1 | New England Patriots vs. Los Angeles Raiders, January 5, 1986 |
| Bob Cifers | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 21, 1947 |
| Don Cockroft | 1 | Cleveland Browns vs. Miami Dolphins, December 24, 1972 |
| Greg Coleman | 1 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Atlanta Falcons, January 9, 1983 |
| Craig Colquitt | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Los Angeles Raiders, January 1, 1984 |
| Craig Colquitt | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Denver Broncos, December 30, 1984 |
| Mike Eischeid | 1 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Washington Redskins, December 22, 1973 |
| Rick Engles | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Denver Broncos, December 24, 1977 |
| Ray Guy | 1 | Oakland Raiders vs. Minnesota Vikings, January 9, 1977 |
| Jeff Hayes | 1 | Washington Redskins vs. Los Angeles Raiders, January 22, 1984 |
| Mitch Hoopes | 1 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, January 18, 1976 |
| Tom Hutton | 1 | Miami Dolphins vs. Jacksonville Jaguars, January 15, 2000 |
| Cecil Isbell | 1 | Green Bay Packers vs. New York Giants, December 11, 1938 |
| Rusty Jackson | 1 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Minnesota Vikings, December 26, 1976 |
| Dave Jennings | 1 | New York Jets vs. Kansas City Chiefs, December 28, 1986 |
| John Jett | 1 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Green Bay Packers, January 14, 1996 |
| David Lee | 1 | Baltimore Colts vs. Oakland Raiders, December 24, 1977 |
| Brad Maynard | 1 | New York Giants vs. Philadelphia Eagles, January 7, 2001 |
| Max McGee | 1 | Green Bay Packers vs. New York Giants, December 30, 1962 |
| Greg Montgomery | 1 | Houston Oilers vs. Buffalo Bills, January 1, 1989 |
| Greg Montgomery | 1 | Houston Oilers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, December 31, 1989 |
| Harry Newsome | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Houston Oilers, December 31, 1989 |
| Rick Partridge | 1 | San Diego Chargers vs. Buffalo Bills, January 3, 1981 |
| Chuck Ramsey | 1 | New York Jets vs. Miami Dolphins, January 23, 1983 |
| Reggie Roby | 1 | Miami Dolphins vs. Kansas City Chiefs, January 5, 1991 |
| Tom Rouen | 1 | Denver Broncos vs. Jacksonville Jaguars, December 27, 1997 |
| Tom Rouen | 1 | Denver Broncos vs. New York Jets, January 17, 1999 |
| Mark Royals | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Kansas City Chiefs, January 8, 1994 |
| Mike Saxon | 1 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Buffalo Bills, January 31, 1993 |
| Bucky Scribner | 1 | Minnesota Vikings vs. San Francisco 49ers, January 6, 1990 |
| Steve Spurrier | 1 | San Francisco 49ers vs. Washington Redskins, December 26, 1971 |
| Tom Tupa | 1 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Oakland Raiders, January 26, 2003 |
| Bobby Walden | 1 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Minnesota Vikings, January 12, 1975 |
| Glen Walker | 1 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Minnesota Vikings, December 31, 1978 |
| Bob Waterfield+ | 1 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 18, 1949 |
| Bob Waterfield+ | 1 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Cleveland Browns, December 23, 1951 |
| 44. | Hamza Abdullah | 0 | Arizona Cardinals vs. Green Bay Packers, January 10, 2010 |
| Hamza Abdullah | 0 | Arizona Cardinals vs. New Orleans Saints, January 16, 2010 |
| Husain Abdullah | 0 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 17, 2010 |
| Husain Abdullah | 0 | Minnesota Vikings vs. New Orleans Saints, January 24, 2010 |
| Karim Abdul-Jabbar | 0 | Miami Dolphins vs. New England Patriots, December 28, 1997 |
| Karim Abdul-Jabbar | 0 | Miami Dolphins vs. Denver Broncos, January 9, 1999 |
| Karim Abdul-Jabbar | 0 | Miami Dolphins vs. Buffalo Bills, January 2, 1999 |