| Rank | Player | TD% | Year | Teams |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Kurt Warner (38) | 15.2% | 2009 | ARI |
| 2. | Bart Starr+ (32) | 14.3% | 1966 | GNB |
| 3. | Steve Young+ (33) | 12.3% | 1994 | SFO |
| 4. | Joe Montana+ (33) | 11.9% | 1989 | SFO |
| 5. | Terry Bradshaw+ (30) | 10.2% | 1978 | PIT |
| 6. | Roger Staubach+ (36) | 10.0% | 1978 | DAL |
| 7. | George Blanda+ (33) | 9.7% | 1960 | HOU |
| 8. | Aaron Rodgers (26) | 9.5% | 2009 | GNB |
| 9. | Troy Aikman+ (26) | 9.4% | 1992 | DAL |
| 10. | Don Strock (31) | 9.3% | 1981 | MIA |
| Kerry Collins (30) | 9.3% | 2002 | NYG | |
| 12. | Joe Flacco (27) | 8.7% | 2012 | BAL |
| 13. | Matt Hasselbeck (35) | 8.6% | 2010 | SEA |
| 14. | Doug Williams (32) | 8.6% | 1987 | WAS |
| 15. | Bernie Kosar (24) | 8.3% | 1987 | CLE |
| John Elway+ (29) | 8.3% | 1989 | DEN | |
| 17. | Kurt Warner (37) | 8.1% | 2008 | ARI |
| 18. | Troy Aikman+ (27) | 8.1% | 1993 | DAL |
| Scott Brunner (24) | 8.1% | 1981 | NYG | |
| 20. | Jeff George (32) | 8.0% | 1999 | MIN |
| Warren Moon+ (36) | 8.0% | 1992 | HOU | |
| 22. | Drew Brees (30) | 7.8% | 2009 | NOR |
| Brett Favre (26) | 7.8% | 1995 | GNB | |
| 24. | Matt Ryan (27) | 7.8% | 2012 | ATL |
| Aaron Brooks (24) | 7.8% | 2000 | NOR |