| 1. | Craig Morton | 26.7% | Denver Broncos vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 15, 1978 |
| 2. | Norm Van Brocklin+ | 24.0% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Cleveland Browns, December 26, 1955 |
| 3. | Frank Filchock | 23.1% | New York Giants vs. Chicago Bears, December 15, 1946 |
| 4. | Mike Phipps | 21.7% | Cleveland Browns vs. Miami Dolphins, December 24, 1972 |
| 5. | Y.A. Tittle+ | 20.0% | New York Giants vs. Green Bay Packers, December 31, 1961 |
| Mark Vlasic | 20.0% | Kansas City Chiefs vs. Buffalo Bills, January 5, 1992 |
| 7. | Dan Pastorini | 19.2% | Houston Oilers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, January 7, 1979 |
| 8. | Bobby Layne+ | 19.0% | Detroit Lions vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 21, 1952 |
| Roger Staubach+ | 19.0% | Dallas Cowboys vs. Minnesota Vikings, December 30, 1973 |
| 10. | Arnie Herber+ | 18.2% | New York Giants vs. Green Bay Packers, December 17, 1944 |
| 11. | Earl Morrall | 17.6% | Baltimore Colts vs. New York Jets, January 12, 1969 |
| 12. | Todd Marinovich | 17.4% | Los Angeles Raiders vs. Kansas City Chiefs, December 28, 1991 |
| Frank Filchock | 17.4% | Washington Redskins vs. Chicago Bears, December 8, 1940 |
| 14. | Y.A. Tittle+ | 17.2% | New York Giants vs. Chicago Bears, December 29, 1963 |
| 15. | George Ratterman | 16.7% | Buffalo Bills vs. Cleveland Browns, December 19, 1948 |
| Eli Manning (24) | 16.7% | New York Giants vs. Carolina Panthers, January 8, 2006 |
| Matt Cassel (28) | 16.7% | Kansas City Chiefs vs. Baltimore Ravens, January 9, 2011 |
| 18. | Jay Schroeder | 16.1% | Los Angeles Raiders vs. Buffalo Bills, January 20, 1991 |
| 19. | Bob Avellini | 16.0% | Chicago Bears vs. Dallas Cowboys, December 26, 1977 |
| 20. | Pat Haden | 15.8% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 7, 1979 |
| 21. | Mike Tomczak | 15.0% | Chicago Bears vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 31, 1988 |
| 22. | Dan Fouts+ | 14.7% | San Diego Chargers vs. Miami Dolphins, January 16, 1983 |
| Jake Delhomme | 14.7% | Carolina Panthers vs. Arizona Cardinals, January 10, 2009 |
| 24. | David Woodley | 14.3% | Miami Dolphins vs. New York Jets, January 23, 1983 |
| Pat Haden | 14.3% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Dallas Cowboys, December 19, 1976 |
| Frank Filchock | 14.3% | Washington Redskins vs. Cleveland Rams, December 16, 1945 |
| Bill Nelsen | 14.3% | Cleveland Browns vs. Baltimore Colts, December 26, 1971 |
| Bobby Layne+ | 14.3% | Detroit Lions vs. Cleveland Browns, December 26, 1954 |
| Paul Christman | 14.3% | Chicago Cardinals vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 28, 1947 |
| Terry Bradshaw+ | 14.3% | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Los Angeles Rams, January 20, 1980 |
| 31. | Scott Mitchell | 13.8% | Detroit Lions vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 30, 1995 |
| Doug Williams | 13.8% | Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 2, 1982 |
| 33. | Brett Favre | 13.6% | Green Bay Packers vs. St. Louis Rams, January 20, 2002 |
| Donovan McNabb | 13.6% | Philadelphia Eagles vs. Carolina Panthers, January 18, 2004 |
| 35. | Richard Todd | 13.5% | New York Jets vs. Miami Dolphins, January 23, 1983 |
| 36. | Joe Montana+ | 13.3% | San Francisco 49ers vs. New York Giants, January 4, 1987 |
| Otto Graham+ | 13.3% | Cleveland Browns vs. Detroit Lions, December 27, 1953 |
| 38. | Gary Danielson | 13.2% | Detroit Lions vs. San Francisco 49ers, December 31, 1983 |
| 39. | Steve Bartkowski | 13.0% | Atlanta Falcons vs. Dallas Cowboys, December 30, 1978 |
| Steve McNair | 13.0% | Tennessee Titans vs. Baltimore Ravens, January 3, 2004 |
| 41. | Bob Waterfield+ | 12.9% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Cleveland Browns, December 24, 1950 |
| 42. | Tommy Kramer | 12.8% | Minnesota Vikings vs. Philadelphia Eagles, January 3, 1981 |
| 43. | Daryle Lamonica | 12.5% | Buffalo Bills vs. Boston Patriots, December 28, 1963 |
| Roger Staubach+ | 12.5% | Dallas Cowboys vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 23, 1973 |
| Bobby Hoying | 12.5% | Oakland Raiders vs. Baltimore Ravens, January 14, 2001 |
| Ben Roethlisberger (22) | 12.5% | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. New England Patriots, January 23, 2005 |
| Roger Staubach+ | 12.5% | Dallas Cowboys vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, January 18, 1976 |
| Vince Ferragamo | 12.5% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 7, 1979 |
| George Blanda+ | 12.5% | Houston Oilers vs. San Diego Chargers, December 24, 1961 |
| Jack Kemp | 12.5% | San Diego Chargers vs. Houston Oilers, December 24, 1961 |
Front Page