| 1. | George Blanda+ | 33.3% | Houston Oilers vs. Dallas Texans, October 28, 1962 |
| Dan Pastorini | 33.3% | Houston Oilers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, October 23, 1977 |
| 3. | Zeke Bratkowski | 31.3% | Chicago Bears vs. Cleveland Browns, December 11, 1960 |
| 4. | Pete Beathard | 28.6% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Atlanta Falcons, October 1, 1972 |
| John Hadl | 28.6% | San Diego Chargers vs. Los Angeles Rams, October 4, 1970 |
| Mike Kirkland | 28.6% | Baltimore Colts vs. Miami Dolphins, October 29, 1978 |
| Tobin Rote | 28.6% | San Diego Chargers vs. Oakland Raiders, October 27, 1963 |
| Phil Simms | 28.6% | New York Giants vs. Baltimore Colts, December 16, 1979 |
| George Wilson | 28.6% | Miami Dolphins vs. Kansas City Chiefs, November 13, 1966 |
| 10. | Jon Kitna | 26.7% | Seattle Seahawks vs. Miami Dolphins, September 3, 2000 |
| Terry Luck | 26.7% | Cleveland Browns vs. Seattle Seahawks, December 18, 1977 |
| Craig Morton | 26.7% | Denver Broncos vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 15, 1978 |
| Bill Munson | 26.7% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Chicago Bears, October 11, 1964 |
| Joe Namath+ | 26.7% | New York Jets vs. Cincinnati Bengals, December 12, 1976 |
| Dan Pastorini | 26.7% | Houston Oilers vs. Cincinnati Bengals, October 31, 1971 |
| Mike Phipps | 26.7% | Cleveland Browns vs. Houston Oilers, October 12, 1975 |
| Frank Ryan | 26.7% | Cleveland Browns vs. St. Louis Cardinals, September 26, 1965 |
| Ken Stabler | 26.7% | Oakland Raiders vs. Green Bay Packers, September 17, 1978 |
| 19. | Larry Rakestraw | 26.3% | Chicago Bears vs. Detroit Lions, September 22, 1968 |
| John Roach | 26.3% | St. Louis Cardinals vs. Cleveland Browns, November 27, 1960 |
| Bart Starr+ | 26.3% | Green Bay Packers vs. Chicago Bears, September 24, 1967 |
| Johnny Unitas+ | 26.3% | Baltimore Colts vs. Detroit Lions, November 20, 1966 |
| 23. | Zeke Bratkowski | 25.0% | Chicago Bears vs. Baltimore Colts, October 2, 1960 |
| Todd Collins | 25.0% | Chicago Bears vs. Carolina Panthers, October 10, 2010 |
| Roman Gabriel | 25.0% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Oakland Raiders, October 29, 1972 |
| John Hadl | 25.0% | San Diego Chargers vs. Kansas City Chiefs, December 8, 1968 |
| Bert Jones | 25.0% | Baltimore Colts vs. New Orleans Saints, September 30, 1973 |
| Joe Namath+ | 25.0% | New York Jets vs. Miami Dolphins, October 19, 1975 |
| Mike Taliaferro | 25.0% | Boston Patriots vs. New York Jets, October 27, 1968 |
| Danny White | 25.0% | Dallas Cowboys vs. Washington Redskins, November 23, 1980 |
| Dick Wood | 25.0% | New York Jets vs. Denver Broncos, November 15, 1964 |
| 32. | Norm Van Brocklin+ | 24.0% | Los Angeles Rams vs. Cleveland Browns, December 26, 1955 |
| 33. | Chuck Pastrana | 23.8% | Denver Broncos vs. Kansas City Chiefs, December 6, 1970 |
| 34. | Jake Delhomme | 23.5% | Carolina Panthers vs. Philadelphia Eagles, September 13, 2009 |
| Tom Flick | 23.5% | San Diego Chargers vs. Kansas City Chiefs, November 2, 1986 |
| Tommy Maddox | 23.5% | Denver Broncos vs. Dallas Cowboys, December 6, 1992 |
| Dan Pastorini | 23.5% | Houston Oilers vs. New York Giants, September 16, 1973 |
| Jack Thompson | 23.5% | Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Chicago Bears, September 2, 1984 |
| Tommy Wade | 23.5% | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Washington Redskins, December 19, 1965 |
| 40. | Frank Filchock | 23.1% | New York Giants vs. Chicago Bears, December 15, 1946 |
| 41. | Babe Parilli | 22.7% | Boston Patriots vs. Kansas City Chiefs, December 14, 1963 |
| 42. | Tony Adams | 22.2% | Kansas City Chiefs vs. Oakland Raiders, December 18, 1977 |
| Steve Bartkowski | 22.2% | Atlanta Falcons vs. New England Patriots, December 4, 1977 |
| John Hadl | 22.2% | San Diego Chargers vs. Kansas City Chiefs, November 14, 1965 |
| John Hadl | 22.2% | San Diego Chargers vs. Cincinnati Bengals, November 28, 1971 |
| Jack Kemp | 22.2% | Buffalo Bills vs. Denver Broncos, September 20, 1964 |
| Daryle Lamonica | 22.2% | Oakland Raiders vs. Baltimore Colts, November 28, 1971 |
| George Mira | 22.2% | San Francisco 49ers vs. Los Angeles Rams, October 18, 1964 |
| Dennis Shaw | 22.2% | Buffalo Bills vs. New York Jets, November 21, 1971 |
| Ken Stabler | 22.2% | Oakland Raiders vs. Kansas City Chiefs, November 14, 1976 |
Front Page