| 1. | Devin Hester (24) | 3 | Chicago Bears vs. Seattle Seahawks, January 14, 2007 |
| Ron Jaworski | 3 | Philadelphia Eagles vs. New York Giants, December 27, 1981 |
| Jack Lambert+ | 3 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Oakland Raiders, January 4, 1976 |
| 4. | Lyle Blackwood | 2 | Baltimore Colts vs. Oakland Raiders, December 24, 1977 |
| Matt Blair | 2 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 26, 1976 |
| Jim Bowman | 2 | New England Patriots vs. Los Angeles Raiders, January 5, 1986 |
| Tom Brady (28) | 2 | New England Patriots vs. Jacksonville Jaguars, January 7, 2006 |
| Tedy Bruschi | 2 | New England Patriots vs. Indianapolis Colts, January 16, 2005 |
| Jeff Bryant | 2 | Seattle Seahawks vs. Los Angeles Raiders, January 8, 1984 |
| Keith Byars | 2 | Philadelphia Eagles vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 31, 1989 |
| Earl Campbell+ | 2 | Houston Oilers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, January 7, 1979 |
| Bobby Carpenter (26) | 2 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Philadelphia Eagles, January 9, 2010 |
| Frank Clarke | 2 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Green Bay Packers, December 31, 1967 |
| Derrick Cullors | 2 | New England Patriots vs. Jacksonville Jaguars, January 3, 1999 |
| Donovin Darius | 2 | Jacksonville Jaguars vs. Miami Dolphins, January 15, 2000 |
| Terrell Davis | 2 | Denver Broncos vs. Kansas City Chiefs, January 4, 1998 |
| Dave Elmendorf | 2 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Minnesota Vikings, December 29, 1974 |
| Jason Gildon | 2 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. New England Patriots, January 3, 1998 |
| Larry Gordon | 2 | Miami Dolphins vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, December 30, 1979 |
| Jerry Gray | 2 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Chicago Bears, January 12, 1986 |
| Bob Griese+ | 2 | Miami Dolphins vs. Oakland Raiders, December 27, 1970 |
| Jack Ham+ | 2 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Houston Oilers, January 7, 1979 |
| Jim Harbaugh | 2 | Indianapolis Colts vs. Kansas City Chiefs, January 7, 1996 |
| Ted Hendricks+ | 2 | Los Angeles Raiders vs. New York Jets, January 15, 1983 |
| Randy Hughes | 2 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Denver Broncos, January 15, 1978 |
| Larry Izzo | 2 | New England Patriots vs. Oakland Raiders, January 19, 2002 |
| Butch Johnson | 2 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Denver Broncos, January 15, 1978 |
| Dub Jones | 2 | Cleveland Browns vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 23, 1951 |
| Jimmie Jones | 2 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Buffalo Bills, January 31, 1993 |
| Bernie Kosar | 2 | Cleveland Browns vs. Denver Broncos, January 14, 1990 |
| Paul Krause+ | 2 | Minnesota Vikings vs. San Francisco 49ers, December 27, 1970 |
| Ray Krouse | 2 | Baltimore Colts vs. New York Giants, December 28, 1958 |
| Fulton Kuykendall | 2 | Atlanta Falcons vs. Philadelphia Eagles, December 24, 1978 |
| Chuck Lamson | 2 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Green Bay Packers, December 23, 1967 |
| Gary Larsen | 2 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Dallas Cowboys, December 30, 1973 |
| Yale Lary+ | 2 | Detroit Lions vs. Los Angeles Rams, December 21, 1952 |
| Joe Laws | 2 | Green Bay Packers vs. Boston Redskins, December 13, 1936 |
| Jim Leonhard (26) | 2 | Baltimore Ravens vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, January 18, 2009 |
| Jack Manders | 2 | Chicago Bears vs. Washington Redskins, December 12, 1937 |
| Harvey Martin | 2 | Dallas Cowboys vs. Minnesota Vikings, January 1, 1978 |
| Brent McClanahan | 2 | Minnesota Vikings vs. Washington Redskins, December 18, 1976 |
| Keith McKeller | 2 | Buffalo Bills vs. Los Angeles Raiders, January 20, 1991 |
| Warren Moon+ | 2 | Houston Oilers vs. New York Jets, December 29, 1991 |
| Warren Moon+ | 2 | Houston Oilers vs. Kansas City Chiefs, January 16, 1994 |
| Gerry Mullins | 2 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Houston Oilers, January 7, 1979 |
| Nelson Munsey | 2 | Baltimore Colts vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, December 27, 1975 |
| Bill Nelsen | 2 | Cleveland Browns vs. Baltimore Colts, December 26, 1971 |
| Vince Newsome | 2 | Los Angeles Rams vs. Dallas Cowboys, January 4, 1986 |
| Ray Nitschke+ | 2 | Green Bay Packers vs. New York Giants, December 30, 1962 |
| Joe Perry+ | 2 | San Francisco 49ers vs. Detroit Lions, December 22, 1957 |