| Year | Player | FGM | Teams |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Shayne Graham (35) | 6 | HOU |
| 2011 | Lawrence Tynes (33) | 8 | NYG |
| 2010 | Billy Cundiff (30) | 4 | BAL |
| 2009 | Matt Stover (41) | 6 | IND |
| 2008 | David Akers (34) | 9 | PHI |
| 2007 | Nate Kaeding (25) | 5 | SDG |
| Lawrence Tynes (29) | 5 | NYG | |
| 2006 | Adam Vinatieri (34) | 14 | IND |
| 2005 | John Kasay (36) | 6 | CAR |
| 2004 | Adam Vinatieri (32) | 5 | NWE |
| 2003 | John Kasay (34) | 9 | CAR |
| 2002 | Sebastian Janikowski (24) | 6 | OAK |
| 2001 | Adam Vinatieri (29) | 6 | NWE |
| David Akers (27) | 6 | PHI | |
| 2000 | Matt Stover (32) | 6 | BAL |
| 1999 | Al Del Greco (37) | 8 | TEN |
| 1998 | Morten Andersen (38) | 7 | ATL |
| 1997 | Ryan Longwell (23) | 6 | GNB |
| 1996 | Mike Hollis (24) | 8 | JAX |
| 1995 | Norm Johnson (35) | 7 | PIT |
| 1994 | Gary Anderson (35) | 4 | PIT |
| Chris Jacke (28) | 4 | GNB | |
| John Carney (30) | 4 | SDG | |
| 1993 | Eddie Murray (37) | 6 | DAL |
| Steve Christie (26) | 6 | BUF | |
| 1992 | Steve Christie (25) | 9 | BUF |
| 1991 | Chip Lohmiller (25) | 6 | WAS |
| 1990 | Matt Bahr (34) | 8 | NYG |
| 1989 | Gary Anderson (30) | 7 | PIT |
| 1988 | Luis Zendejas (27) | 4 | PHI |
| 1987 | Chuck Nelson (27) | 9 | MIN |
| 1986 | Rich Karlis (27) | 7 | DEN |
| 1985 | Tony Franklin (29) | 8 | NWE |
| 1984 | Uwe von Schamann (28) | 5 | MIA |
| 1983 | Chris Bahr (30) | 5 | RAI |
| Mark Moseley (35) | 5 | WAS | |
| 1982 | Rafael Septien (29) | 7 | DAL |
| 1981 | Ray Wersching (31) | 5 | SFO |
| 1980 | Chris Bahr (27) | 6 | OAK |
| 1979 | Frank Corral (24) | 5 | RAM |
| Toni Fritsch (34) | 5 | HOU | |
| 1978 | Roy Gerela (30) | 4 | PIT |
| 1977 | Efren Herrera (26) | 6 | DAL |
| 1976 | Errol Mann (35) | 4 | OAK |
| 1975 | Toni Fritsch (30) | 5 | DAL |
| 1974 | David Ray (30) | 3 | RAM |
| Roy Gerela (26) | 3 | PIT | |
| 1973 | Garo Yepremian (29) | 5 | MIA |
| George Blanda+ (46) | 5 | OAK | |
| 1972 | Curt Knight (29) | 7 | WAS |